Swimming is more than just a sport—it’s a way of life, a test of endurance, and often a deeply personal journey. Books about swimming offer a glimpse into the mental, physical, and emotional landscapes of elite athletes. Two recent memoirs, Katie Ledecky’s “Just Add Water” and Becca Mann’s “Outside the Lanes,” showcase contrasting storytelling styles and offer unique insights into the lives of these elite swimmers.
These books are notable not only because of their high-profile authorship but also because they come from swimmers who have crossed paths—literally and figuratively. While each book offers valuable perspectives, their styles and focus vary significantly, leaving readers with two very different experiences.
Katie Ledecky’s Just Add Water: Snapshots of Influence
Katie Ledecky is renowned for her unparalleled success in the pool, breaking records, winning gold medals, and inspiring countless swimmers to pursue their dreams. Her memoir, Add Water, reveals glimpses into the life behind the accolades, but it does so in a somewhat unconventional way. Rather than presenting a cohesive narrative, Ledecky structures her book more like a collection of vignettes. Each chapter highlights specific people who have shaped her athletic and personal development, including her parents, coaches, sibling, grandparents, and teammates.
Strengths of Ledecky’s Approach
One of the standout features of Add Water is the focus on gratitude. Ledecky’s humility shines through as she details how her support network bolstered her success, portraying her achievements not as solitary triumphs but as the result of a team effort. This theme of interconnectedness may resonate with readers who value the role of community and mentorship in athletic development.
The book also offers inspirational moments, particularly for aspiring swimmers. Ledecky shares her wisdom from her experiences, such as the importance of discipline, the value of long-term commitment, and her process for setting and achieving high goals.
Missed Opportunities in Storytelling
However, the lack of a cohesive storyline may leave some readers unsatisfied. Each chapter serves as its isolated reflection, and while this format highlights Ledecky’s relationships and experiences, it doesn’t provide the narrative arc many readers look for in a memoir. What’s missing is a closer look at Ledecky’s internal world during pivotal moments, such as her climb to Olympic glory. What was she thinking and feeling as she prepared for races that would define her career? How did she handle the pressure, the setbacks, and the triumphs? For readers wanting to connect with Ledecky on a deeper level, these omissions may feel like a missed opportunity.
Ledecky also doesn’t touch on her interactions with fellow swimmers during events like the Olympic trials. Given that Becca Mann was one of her competitors, such details could have enriched the book with a sense of camaraderie—or healthy rivalry—within their shared swimming community.
Becca Mann’s Outside the Lanes: A Compelling Narrative
Becca Mann’s memoir, Outside the Lanes, takes a markedly different approach. Mann delivers a structured, gripping coming-of-age story that follows her personal and athletic growth from a determined child swimmer to an elite-level open-water swimmer. The narrative is straightforward and purposeful, driven by a sense of focus that hooks readers and keeps them engaged.
Why Mann’s Story Stands Out
Where Ledecky opts for snapshots, Mann offers the whole picture. Her story begins in her early years and traces her evolution with an element of vulnerability that feels raw and relatable. One of the most notable aspects of the book is her decision to leave home at the age of 13 to pursue her swimming dreams—a bold move that underscores her intense drive and commitment. Mann doesn’t shy away from sharing the highs and lows of this decision, giving readers an intimate glimpse into the price of greatness.
Mann’s candid voice also sets her book apart. She openly discusses her love of open-water swimming, distinguishing her career path from Ledecky’s pool-focused achievements. For instance, she reveals that open-water events are her passion because of their unpredictability and the intimate connection to nature. This contrasts with Ledecky’s comment that she prefers pool swimming because the open water, with its lack of visibility, isn’t as appealing.
The book culminates in a powerful conclusion illustrating the resolve required to overcome doubts and setbacks. Mann’s reflections tie the story together, leaving readers with a sense of closure and admiration for her grit.
A Flawed But Engaging Voice
That said, Mann’s voice occasionally comes across as overly self-assured. Some readers might perceive her tone as being tinged with arrogance, especially when she highlights her achievements or discusses her rivals in the field. While this confidence may align with the mindset required to succeed at the highest levels, it may not resonate with everyone. Still, for many readers, Mann’s determination and authenticity shine through, making her story inspiring despite these occasional missteps.
Shared History, Unique Perspectives
One intriguing thread that connects these books is the authors’ shared experience at the Olympic trials. While Mann writes about these moments candidly in Outside the Lanes, Ledecky’s Just Add Water omits specific mentions of competing against Mann. This dynamic adds another layer of contrast between the two books. Mann’s willingness to acknowledge and reflect on her encounters with competitors enriches her narrative, while Ledecky’s exclusion of such details keeps her focus broader and less personal.
What Each Book Offers Readers
For swimmers and fans of elite-level sports, both books offer valuable takeaways—but in different ways.
- **Just Add Water by Katie Ledecky** is a tribute to the people who supported her and propelled her to greatness. It’s an inspirational read for those who value the power of teamwork and mentorship. However, readers seeking a more personal and introspective story may find the book lacking in depth.
- **Outside the Lanes by Becca Mann**, on the other hand, delivers a captivating personal narrative. It’s a book that swims deep into the challenges and triumphs of an elite athlete’s life. Mann’s honesty and the book’s narrative structure make it a compelling read.
Ultimately, the choice between these memoirs comes down to what kind of story you’re looking for. Whether you’re drawn to Ledecky’s gratitude-centered perspective or Mann’s raw and determined voice, both books provide a window into the world of swimming at its highest levels. For athletes, fans, and curious readers alike, these contrasting approaches offer complementary insights into what it takes to succeed in—and out of—the water.